Mpix and Shutterfly both offer gallery-wrapped canvas prints made from supplied images. Mpix specifies a 1.5-inch stretcher and three float-frame colors; Shutterfly's creation guide details its photo templates and editing steps. CanvasGenie is another option when you want to create art from an idea or photo reference before choosing a canvas.
CanvasGenie publishes this guide and is our product.
Mpix vs Shutterfly canvas prints at a glance
Mpix's product page describes photo resolution, collage templates, and text on canvas. Shutterfly's guide describes template selection, photo upload, layout changes, and text editing. We checked the US product pages on October 14, 2026; Shutterfly's how-to guide was last updated July 15, 2026.
| Canvas choice | Mpix | Shutterfly |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | Mpix recommends uploading a full-resolution photo that suits the selected size. It also offers canvas collage templates. Mpix canvas details | Shutterfly's guide starts with a single-photo, collage, or upload-your-own-design template, then adds photos from a device or connected account. Shutterfly canvas guide |
| Set sizes | Mpix's page lists sizes from 8×10 to 40×60 inches and says custom dimensions are not offered. Mpix size list | Shutterfly's guide gives a size range from 8×10 to 36×36 inches. Its catalog has size choices by design. Shutterfly size guide, canvas catalog |
| Collages and editing | Mpix offers dedicated canvas collage templates and says you can add personalized text to the image or wrapped edges. Mpix collage options | Shutterfly offers single-photo and multi-photo designs. Its guide describes zooming, rotating, repositioning photos, changing layouts, and editing text before ordering. Shutterfly editor guide |
| Wrap and frame | Mpix specifies a 1.5-inch wood stretcher, Oxford brown, black, or white float frames, and size-dependent hanging hardware. Mpix materials and framing | Shutterfly offers gallery-wrapped and framed choices. The pages reviewed do not state the frame depth. Shutterfly canvas catalog, creation guide |
| Best fit | A straightforward print order using Mpix's published fixed size list and optional float framing. | A template-led project with several photos, editable text, or layout changes. |
Which canvas sizes do Mpix and Shutterfly offer?
Shutterfly's canvas guide, last updated July 15, 2026, gives a range up to 36×36 inches. Mpix's canvas page lists sizes up to 40×60 inches.
For placement ideas, see the canvas size guide and our guide to choosing a canvas size above a couch. Mpix says on its canvas product page that listed dimensions refer to the front surface and do not include the wrapped edge; Shutterfly's catalog lists sizes by design.
How do Mpix and Shutterfly handle photos and collages?
Mpix's canvas page recommends a full-resolution photo for the chosen size and links to collage templates. Shutterfly's creation guide describes adding photos, repositioning or rotating them, trying another layout, and editing text or backgrounds when the template allows it.
If you already have a finished image and want a direct photo-to-canvas order, either service may suit you. Shutterfly's published workflow covers collage layouts and editable text.
When does CanvasGenie make sense?
Choose CanvasGenie when the art itself is still an open question. You can describe an idea from scratch or provide a photo reference with a description to guide a new interpretation. The photo-reference path creates artwork inspired by the photo; it is not a way to print that exact photo unchanged. For a conventional photo print, Mpix or Shutterfly is the more direct fit.
CanvasGenie offers gallery-wrapped and framed canvas formats. Current sizes, frame choices, and catalog-based price estimates appear in the product tables below; checkout shows the order total. Printful is CanvasGenie's fulfiller, and US production is available for both formats. Its catalog lists the US as a sourcing country for gallery-wrapped canvas and framed canvas. Printful routes orders automatically based on destination, stock, technique, and capacity, so the production facility can vary.
If you want to compare finishes first, see gallery-wrapped canvas prints and framed canvas prints. For ideas made from prompts and reference images, read how AI art works on canvas.
Which one should you choose?
- Pick Mpix for a photo-led canvas with its published fixed size list, several float-frame colors, and an optional collage template.
- Pick Shutterfly for a template-led collage where you expect to rearrange photos or edit text before checkout.
- Pick CanvasGenie when you want to generate original artwork from a written idea or use a photo to guide a new artistic interpretation.
Check the live size and framing options for your chosen design, then review the crop at full size before ordering.
Frequently asked questions
Can Mpix print a canvas without the wood stretcher?
No. Mpix says it does not offer unwrapped canvas prints; its canvas is stretched around a wood frame.
Can I save a Shutterfly canvas project and finish it later?
Yes. Shutterfly says saved projects can be reopened and edited before you place the order.
Can I hang an Mpix canvas in a humid room?
Mpix says its canvas prints are not designed for high-humidity rooms because moisture can warp the wood frame.